Predictive Index Alternatives: 7 Options for Cognitive and Behavioral Hiring Tests

Predictive Index Alternatives: 7 Options for Cognitive and Behavioral Hiring Tests

As of November 2026, the Predictive Index (PI) alternatives that scored highest on our five criteria are TestGorilla and Alva Labs, followed by Criteria Corp and Thomas International. All four pair a cognitive test with a personality or behavioral measure, which is what PI does. We also cover Wonderlic Select, Culture Index and our own free Career Potential Test (CPT). The CPT is one general cognitive test: it has no behavioral or personality half and no after-hire tools, so it can stand in for PI's cognitive test only.

PI sells one yearly platform rather than single tests. Its plans page says plans "start at $10,000 per year," priced by company size, with no monthly option and no way to buy assessments one at a time. That price floor is the usual reason employers shop around, although PI also offers more for managing people after the hire than most tools here.

CourseCareers makes the CPT, so this page isn't neutral. We publish the criteria, weights and scoring rules below, applied them the same way to every option, and read each vendor's own pages in November 2026. The CPT placed sixth of seven: being free lifts its price and trial scores, but it covers only one half of PI and nothing after the hire.

Key takeaways

  • PI's plans start at $10,000 a year on an annual contract, with unlimited users and unlimited assessments.
  • PI pairs a 12-minute, 50-question Cognitive Assessment with an untimed Behavioral Assessment of about six minutes.
  • TestGorilla's Free plan includes a 9-minute Problem Solving test and a 10-minute Big 5 personality test with unlimited use.
  • Alva Labs, Criteria, Thomas International and Wonderlic all pair cognitive and personality tests, but none lists a dollar price.
  • Culture Index sells a behavioral survey of under 8 minutes; we found no cognitive test on its pages.
  • Our free CPT is one general cognitive test with no behavioral half and no after-hire tools. It's new, and we haven't published validation studies.

Need only the cognitive half of PI?

The Career Potential Test is free for employers and candidates, needs no account, and gives you a percentile and section scores.

See the CPT for employers

What's on this page

What does the Predictive Index include, and what does it cost?

PI is two assessments wrapped in a people-management platform.

  • PI Behavioral Assessment. PI's Behavioral Assessment page describes "a six-minute, untimed workplace assessment" built on two questions about one shared list of adjectives: how you're expected to act at work and how you'd describe yourself. It scores four drives (dominance, extraversion, patience and formality) and sorts people into one of 17 Reference Profiles.
  • PI Cognitive Assessment. The Cognitive Assessment page lists 50 questions in 12 minutes covering verbal, numerical and abstract reasoning, with 18-minute and 24-minute versions offered as ADA accommodations. Each candidate gets a unique set of items.
  • The platform. PI's plans page groups features into Hire (job targets, match scores, interview guides), Develop (coaching and manager guides) and Build & Grow (team composition and action plans).

On price, the same page says plans "start at $10,000 per year" and are custom-priced by company size. Its FAQ adds that there's no monthly subscription and that assessments can't be bought individually. The page we read lists unlimited behavioral assessments under Hire but doesn't say whether the Cognitive Assessment is included in every plan, so ask PI's sales team if that matters to you. Job seekers can read our Predictive Index test guide.

How do the Predictive Index alternatives compare?

Here's what each option offers next to PI, using only what each vendor's own site said when we read it in November 2026. Times are what the vendor publishes for a typical candidate.

OptionCognitive testBehavioral or personality measurePublished priceTry it first
The Predictive Index (reference)50 questions, 12 minutesBehavioral Assessment, about 6 minutes, untimedFrom $10,000 a yearFree trial arranged through sales
TestGorillaProblem Solving, 12 questions in 9 minutes, plus other library testsBig 5 (OCEAN), 10 minutesFree plan; Core from $215 a month, billed annuallyFree plan
Alva LabsLogic test, about 15 minutes, adaptivePersonality test on the Five-Factor Model, 12 to 15 minutesPer hire by annual volume; rates not listed30-day free trial (sign-up steps not described)
Criteria CorpCCAT, 50 items in 15 minutesEmployee Personality Profile, 140 items, about 10 minutesQuote based on headcount14-day free trial through a sign-up form
Thomas InternationalGeneral Intelligence Assessment, about 45 minutesDISC-based behavioral assessment, 24 questions, under 8 minutesPer employee per month; no amount in the page text we readNone mentioned
Wonderlic Select50 questions in 12 minutes150 personality and 58 motivation items; about 35 minutes in allQuote by package and employee countNone mentioned for employers
Culture IndexNone found on its pagesCI Survey, under 8 minutesNot publishedFree diagnostic (contents not described)
Career Potential Test (ours)55 adaptive questions, four 15-minute sectionsNoneFreeFree

Only TestGorilla and the CPT publish a price you can act on without a sales call. Cognitive test length also varies a lot, from 9 minutes to about 45.

How did we score the alternatives?

We set five criteria and weights, then scored each option from 1 (weak) to 5 (strong) on what its own site showed in November 2026. The scoring rules below were applied the same way to every option, including ours.

  1. Both halves (30%). Does one vendor offer a cognitive test and a behavioral or personality measure, as PI does? 5 = both, sold together; 4 = both, but as separate library tests you combine yourself; 1 = only one half.
  2. Published price (20%). Can you see a cost without talking to sales? 5 = dollar prices published, or free; 3 = a starting price published; 2 = the unit of charge published (per hire, per employee) but no amounts; 1 = quote only or not published.
  3. Try before you commit (15%). 5 = free plan or free to use; 4 = an advertised free trial with a stated length; 3 = a trial available on request through sales; 2 = a free sample tool that isn't a trial; 1 = none mentioned.
  4. Candidate time (15%). Total time for the vendor's published cognitive plus behavioral pairing (or its single test). 5 = 20 minutes or less; 4 = 21 to 30; 3 = 31 to 40; 2 = 41 to 60; 1 = over 60.
  5. After-hire tools (20%). Help with coaching, managers or team design, like PI's Develop and Build & Grow features. 5 = coaching, manager guidance and team tools in the main platform; 3 = some post-hire tools, partial or sold as an add-on or separate product; 1 = none described.
RankOptionBoth halvesPriceTrialTimeAfter-hireWeighted
ReferenceThe Predictive Index533554.30
1TestGorilla455513.90
2Alva Labs524433.70
3Criteria Corp514433.50
4Thomas International521253.35
5Wonderlic Select511332.90
6Career Potential Test (ours)155212.55
7Culture Index112532.15

Weighted = (both halves x 0.30) + (price x 0.20) + (trial x 0.15) + (time x 0.15) + (after-hire x 0.20). For example, TestGorilla: 1.20 + 1.00 + 0.75 + 0.75 + 0.20 = 3.90.

Notes on the scores:

  • PI scores highest because our criteria describe what it does. If price isn't the problem, staying may be right.
  • TestGorilla, both halves (4): the two tests are separate library items you combine, and we didn't see a single PI-style job match score on the pages we read.
  • Thomas, time (2): its 45-minute GIA plus the behavioral assessment comes close to an hour.
  • Criteria and Wonderlic, after-hire (3): both sell a separate development product (Criteria Develop as an add-on, Wonderlic Develop alongside Select).
  • Culture Index, both halves (1): we found no cognitive test, so it replaces only PI's behavioral half.
  • The CPT, both halves (1) and after-hire (1): it is one general cognitive test with no behavioral or personality section and no tools for managing people after the hire. Its price and trial scores are high only because it's free, so don't read its rank as a judgment on test quality.

What does each Predictive Index alternative offer?

TestGorilla

The pricing page lists a Free plan with 10 credits a month and five tests with unlimited use, including Problem Solving and Big 5 (OCEAN). Paid plans start at $215 a month (Core) and $520 a month (Plus), billed annually. The Problem Solving factsheet gives 12 questions in 9 minutes, and the Big 5 page lists 10 minutes. Pick it to start at $0 and build your own pairing.

Alva Labs

Alva pairs an adaptive logic test (about 15 minutes, with a 2-minute window per question) with an adaptive personality test built on the Five-Factor Model (12 to 15 minutes). Its pricing page charges per hire by annual volume, with "no platform fee, no per-seat licence," but lists no rates. A 30-day free trial is offered.

Criteria Corp

Criteria's CCAT has 50 items in 15 minutes, and its Employee Personality Profile has 140 items that take about 10 minutes. The plans page offers Assess, Interview and Hire packages priced around your headcount, with Criteria Develop as a post-hire add-on. Its free trial page offers a 14-day trial for employers through a sign-up form. Suits teams that also want video interviews from one vendor.

Thomas International

Thomas's pricing page prices per employee per month, with a minimum spend for organizations under 100 employees. The Team plan has the behavioral assessment only; Professional adds personality, aptitude (the GIA) and emotional intelligence; Expert adds 360 feedback. The GIA page says it takes 45 minutes, and the behavioral assessment page says 24 questions in under 8 minutes. The closest match to PI's full people-management scope.

Wonderlic Select

Wonderlic's Select page combines cognitive ability, personality and motivation into one job-fit score, with role benchmarks, ranked shortlists and structured interview guides. Its candidate FAQ gives the 12-minute, 50-question cognitive section and says most people finish everything in about 35 minutes. Pricing depends on the package and employee count. For after the hire, Wonderlic sells a separate product, Wonderlic Develop, with growth plans and a Team Dynamics Report.

Culture Index

The products page describes the CI Survey as a behavioral assessment with results in under 8 minutes, and says it works for candidates, employees and leaders. The same page lists job benchmark, structured interview and outcome-tracking tools, but describes no coaching or development product. No price is published. Consider it only if you used PI mainly for its behavioral profiles.

Can you replace only one half of the Predictive Index?

Yes, and many teams should. Ask which PI output actually changes your hiring decisions.

  • You mostly use the cognitive score. A standalone aptitude test is cheaper and simpler. The CCAT, TestGorilla's Problem Solving test and our CPT all fit. Our CCAT alternatives comparison lines up the cognitive tests side by side.
  • You mostly use behavioral profiles for managing people. Thomas's Team plan (behavioral only) and Culture Index are the closest fits, since both describe tools for employees and leaders, not only candidates.
  • You want cognitive, personality and motivation in one score. Wonderlic Select is built for that. Our Wonderlic alternatives page covers that product's rivals.

Behavioral tools describe style, not ability, so use a profile to shape interview questions rather than as a pass or fail line. Our guide to whether aptitude tests are legal covers consistency and accommodations.

When should you stay with the Predictive Index?

PI is a strong product, and leaving it isn't always a saving. Stay if most of these apply:

  • Managers use it after the hire. If PI profiles feed one-on-ones, team design or coaching, Thomas comes closest among the options we read. Criteria and Wonderlic sell development products separately.
  • You test a lot of people. PI's price covers unlimited assessments. As an example, at $10,000 a year, 200 candidates works out to $50 each, while 1,000 candidates works out to $10 each. Per-candidate tools can cost more at high volume.
  • You need short, accommodated cognitive testing. PI's 12-minute test with 18- and 24-minute versions and unique item sets per candidate is hard to beat for speed.
  • Your systems are already connected. PI's plans page cites 97+ integrations, and its TestGorilla comparison page names native Greenhouse and Paylocity integrations.

If you're mainly reacting to the $10,000 floor, compare it with the per-candidate costs in our pre-employment test pricing guide before you switch.

Where does the Career Potential Test fit as a PI alternative?

The CPT is one general cognitive test, so it replaces only the PI Cognitive Assessment, and it works differently. It has 55 adaptive questions across Critical Thinking, Reading, Writing and Math, with each section timed at 15 minutes, so it takes up to an hour instead of 12 minutes. It's proctored by webcam on a desktop or laptop. Candidates see a percentile and section breakdown right away and send you a results link.

Setup takes under five minutes and needs no account: point applicants to the test in your posting. Our employer page suggests listing it as an optional qualification, for example: "An 80%+ CPT score may be submitted in lieu of relevant experience."

The honest limits:

  • No behavioral or personality data. If you relied on PI's Reference Profiles, the CPT won't replace them.
  • No after-hire tools. There's nothing for coaching, managers or team design, so it doesn't replace PI's Develop or Build & Grow features.
  • It's new. We haven't published validation studies, so we can't show how scores relate to job performance.
  • One signal, not a credential. Use it as one data point among several, applied the same way to everyone, and don't make it the only reason to reject someone. Any pre-employment test has to follow employment law (in the U.S., EEOC guidance).
  • We have a stake. The CPT is free because we may introduce candidates you don't hire to CourseCareers courses.

Our recommendation: Decide first which half of PI you use. If you need both halves and want to start for free, pilot TestGorilla's Free plan; if you'd rather pay per hire, trial Alva Labs. If managers rely on PI after the hire, get a Thomas quote or stay with PI. If you only need a cognitive signal for entry-level roles, try the free CPT as an optional qualification and judge it on your own hires.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a cheaper alternative to the Predictive Index?
TestGorilla has a Free plan that includes a problem solving test and a Big 5 personality test, and paid plans from $215 a month billed annually. Our Career Potential Test is free but covers only the cognitive side.

How much does the Predictive Index cost?
PI's plans page says plans start at $10,000 per year, custom-priced by company size, on an annual contract. Assessments can't be bought one at a time.

Is there a free version of the Predictive Index?
PI offers a free six-minute Behavioral Assessment for individuals and says it can enable a free trial through sales. There's no free employer plan on the pages we read.

What test is most similar to the PI Cognitive Assessment?
Wonderlic Select's cognitive section matches PI's format (50 questions in 12 minutes), and the CCAT is close (50 items in 15 minutes).

Is the Culture Index the same as the Predictive Index?
No. Both sell behavioral surveys, but they're different companies, and we found no cognitive test on Culture Index's pages, while PI also offers a Cognitive Assessment.

Can the Career Potential Test replace the Predictive Index?
Only the cognitive part. The CPT measures critical thinking, reading, writing and math, and has no behavioral or personality section.

Add a free cognitive signal to your hiring

List the Career Potential Test as an optional qualification. Candidates take it free and send you their percentile and section scores.

Set up the CPT for free

Sources