How to Assess SDR Candidates: Sales Tests, Role-Plays and a Free Aptitude Screen

How to Assess SDR Candidates: Sales Tests, Role-Plays and a Free Aptitude Screen

The most useful way to assess sales development representative (SDR) candidates is to watch them do small versions of the job: a scored mock cold call, a short cold-email writing exercise and a structured interview with the same questions for everyone. A sales trait questionnaire (such as Criteria's SalesAP or Objective Management Group's candidate assessment) and a general aptitude test can add signal, but they work best as inputs, not gates.

This guide is for hiring managers and founders building an SDR process, including for candidates with no sales experience. It covers what to test, how to score each exercise, and where the legal risks are.

We make the free Career Potential Test (CPT), one of the aptitude options mentioned here, and we train people for SDR jobs in our Technology Sales course. So we aren't neutral, and we say plainly where the CPT does and doesn't help.

Key takeaways

  • Test the tasks SDRs do daily: researching a prospect, opening a call, handling a brush-off, writing a short email and asking for a meeting.
  • Score every exercise on a written 1 to 5 rubric, set before you see any candidate, so interviewers agree and decisions hold up.
  • OPM says structured interviews relate highly to job performance and cost little to build, which makes them the backbone of an SDR process.
  • Criteria's SalesAP has 140 items at a sixth-grade reading level and adjusts scores for applicants who exaggerate.
  • OPM notes cognitive tests tend to show larger group differences than other valid tools, so pair any aptitude test with other measures.
  • The free CPT can be an optional qualification. It isn't sales-specific, it's new, and we haven't published validation studies.

Add a free aptitude signal to SDR hiring

List the Career Potential Test as an optional qualification so applicants without sales experience can show reasoning, reading, writing and math.

See the CPT for employers

What's on this page

What should you test for when hiring an SDR?

Write down what a good SDR does in their first 90 days, then test those things directly. The Bureau of Labor Statistics' Occupational Outlook Handbook entry for sales representatives lists customer-service skills (listening to "the customer's needs and concerns"), interpersonal skills and self-confidence ("confident and persuasive when making sales presentations") as important qualities. It also notes many reps learn through formal company training, so you're hiring for the ability to learn the job, not for finished skill.

For an SDR role, that usually maps to six things:

What to assessWhy it matters for SDRsBest way to check it
Prospect researchGood outreach starts with a reason to callGive 15 minutes to research a real company, then ask what they found
Phone composureCalls often open with a brush-offMock cold call with a scripted objection
Clear, short writingEmail is a core SDR channelTimed cold-email exercise
CoachabilityNew SDRs are coached on the jobGive feedback mid-role-play and watch the second attempt
Drive and resilienceHigh daily activity with a lot of "no"Structured interview questions about past goals and setbacks
Learning speed and reasoningNew product, tools and buyer language in weeksOptional aptitude test, plus how fast they absorb your role-play brief

Leave off what you'll teach anyway. If your team trains new hires on your CRM, your product and your call framework, testing those before hire screens out people who'd learn them fine. OPM's work samples page makes the same point: if training "will be provided after selection, the work sample method may not be appropriate." Keep exercises to the basics anyone could prepare for.

Which SDR assessment methods should you use?

Here's how the common methods compare, using OPM's descriptions and each publisher's own pages, read in November 2026:

MethodWhat it showsCandidate time (example)Cost to youNotes
Structured interviewPast behavior and judgment, scored the same way for everyone30 to 45 minutesInterviewer timeOPM: low development cost, small group differences
Mock cold callComposure, listening, objection handling, the meeting ask15 to 20 minutes with prepInterviewer timeA work sample; OPM says applicants often see these as fair
Cold-email exerciseResearch, clarity, a specific ask20 to 30 minutesReviewer timeUse a fictional or public company, never your live prospects
Sales trait questionnaireSelf-reported sales drive and styleVaries; SalesAP has 140 itemsCriteria and OMG publish no prices on the pages we readAnswers are self-reported; publishers add faking checks
General aptitude testReasoning, reading, writing, math12 minutes (PI) to an hour (CPT)From $0 (CPT) to quote-onlyOPM flags larger group differences; never use alone

The times are examples from our own suggested process, not vendor figures. A reasonable order for most teams: a short phone screen, then the cold-email exercise, then a final round with the structured interview and the mock call. Add a questionnaire or aptitude test only if it answers a question the exercises don't.

For the candidate's view of the same process, see our sales aptitude test guide for job seekers.

How do you run and score a mock cold call?

Make it realistic and the same for everyone.

  1. Send a one-page brief 24 hours ahead. Name the product, the prospect's role, one pain it solves and the goal: a booked 20-minute meeting, not a sale.
  2. Play one consistent prospect. Write your lines down: a busy opener ("I've got two minutes"), one objection ("We already have a vendor for that") and a soft no ("Send me some information").
  3. Run it for about eight minutes.
  4. Give one piece of coaching, such as "ask a question before you pitch," then run it again for three minutes.
  5. Score both rounds on your rubric before talking to other interviewers.

An example rubric, scored 1 to 5 per line:

Skill1 (weak)5 (strong)
OpenerLong introduction, no reason for the callName, company and a relevant reason in two sentences
DiscoveryPitches immediatelyAsks about the prospect's current process and listens
Objection handlingArgues or gives upAcknowledges, asks one more question, stays calm
The askNo clear next stepProposes a specific short meeting at a specific time
CoachabilityRepeats the same approachUses the feedback in round two

The coachability line often matters more than the polish of round one. A career changer who has never cold called may start at 2s and jump to 4s after one tip, which is what you'll see every week on the job. Our list of SDR skills new hires build can help you decide which lines matter most for your team.

What should a cold-email writing exercise look like?

Keep it short, timed and clearly unpaid practice, not real work for your company.

An example prompt: "You sell scheduling software to dental offices. Pick any dental group with a public website. In 25 minutes, write a first-touch email of 120 words or less to its office manager, plus a subject line. Then add two sentences on why you chose your angle."

Score it on:

  • Relevance: does the email mention something specific to that prospect?
  • Length and clarity: can the main point be read in ten seconds?
  • One clear ask: a specific, low-effort next step.
  • Mechanics: spelling, grammar and tone.
  • Reasoning: do the two sentences show they thought about the buyer?

Two cautions. Use a fictional product or a public company so you never collect free prospecting on your real accounts. And tell candidates whether they may use AI writing tools. If you allow them, ask for a quick verbal walkthrough of their choices in the final round, so you're scoring their judgment, not a tool's output.

How do you structure the SDR interview?

A structured interview asks every candidate the same questions and scores answers against benchmarks written in advance. OPM's structured interviews page says "performance on structured interviews relates highly to performance on the job," that they can add validity beyond other measures, and that development costs are generally low.

OPM describes two question styles. Use both:

  • Behavioral (past): "Tell me about a time you set a goal that took daily effort for weeks. What did you track, and what happened?"
  • Behavioral (past): "Describe a time you got a flat no. What did you do next?"
  • Situational (future): "You've sent 60 emails this week and booked nothing. What do you change on Monday?"
  • Situational (future): "A prospect says, 'Just email me.' How do you respond, and why?"

For each question, write what a 1, 3 and 5 answer sound like before the first interview. A 5 answer to the "flat no" question might name the setback, describe a specific change in approach, and show the result. A 1 answer blames others or has no example.

Candidates without sales jobs can still give strong answers from retail, restaurants, sports, school or fundraising. Score the behavior, not the setting. Have each interviewer rate on their own before you discuss, which OPM notes is how panels usually handle scoring.

If you're also hiring entry-level people for other roles, our guide to screening candidates with no experience covers application questions and reference checks.

Add one if you'll use it consistently and it measures something your exercises miss.

Sales trait questionnaires. Criteria's SalesAP page lists 140 items scoring Achievement, Cold Calling Initiative, Competitiveness, Sales Closing and Sales Disposition, with validity scales that adjust scores for applicants who "exaggerate strengths or minimize weaknesses." Objective Management Group's candidate assessment page covers 21 sales competencies in three groups (Will to Sell, Sales DNA and Tactical Selling), can be set up for inside sales and other roles, and marks each candidate Recommended or Not Recommended. Neither page we read publishes a price.

General cognitive tests. These estimate how fast someone learns. OPM's cognitive ability tests page says they're "good predictors of job performance and training success," but also that they "typically produce racial and ethnic differences larger than other valid predictors," and recommends combining them with tools like interviews. Criteria's CCAT (50 items, 15 minutes) and PI's 12-minute Cognitive Assessment are common paid choices.

The legal basics, in short:

  • Job-related and consistent with business necessity. The EEOC's fact sheet on employment tests uses this test when a procedure screens out a protected group at a higher rate.
  • Accommodations. The same fact sheet says failing to make reasonable accommodations "in the administration of tests" for qualified applicants with disabilities is unlawful under the ADA.
  • Medical questions. OPM's personality tests page notes that tests designed to diagnose psychiatric conditions count as medical exams under the ADA and can only be given after a job offer. Stick to tools built for hiring.
  • Consistency. Give every candidate for the role the same steps, in the same order, scored the same way, and check whether pass rates differ by group.

Our guide to whether pre-employment aptitude tests are legal covers adverse impact and the four-fifths rule in more depth. This isn't legal advice; talk to an employment lawyer about your own process.

Where does the free Career Potential Test fit in SDR hiring?

The CPT is a general aptitude test, not a sales test. It has 55 adaptive questions across Critical Thinking, Reading, Writing and Math, each section timed at 15 minutes, proctored by webcam on a desktop or laptop. Candidates take it free on their own and send you a results link with a percentile and a section breakdown. Reading and writing scores are relevant to SDR work, since so much of it is reading prospect information and writing short emails.

How we suggest using it: as an optional qualification, not a required step. Our employer page gives example posting wording: "Bachelor's degree or 1+ year of relevant work experience required. An 80%+ CPT score may be submitted in lieu of relevant experience." That opens the door to career changers without asking every applicant to spend up to an hour on a test.

Its limits, plainly:

  • It doesn't measure sales traits, phone skills or writing style. Your role-play, email exercise and interview still do that work.
  • It's new. We haven't published validation studies, so we can't show how CPT scores relate to SDR performance.
  • A score is one signal, not a credential. Use it as one data point among several, applied consistently, never as the only reason to reject someone.
  • No employer dashboard. You see only what candidates share, and their results page shows the most recent attempt.
  • We have a stake. The CPT is free because we may introduce candidates you don't hire to CourseCareers courses, such as our Technology Sales course.

Our recommendation: Build your SDR process around three exercises scored on written rubrics: a cold-email task, a mock call with one round of coaching, and a structured interview. Add a sales questionnaire or a cognitive test only if you'll give it to every candidate and treat it as one input. If you want more applicants without sales backgrounds, list the free CPT as an optional "or" qualification and let the exercises decide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best test for hiring SDRs?
No single test covers the job. A mock cold call, a short cold-email exercise and a structured interview test the actual work, and a sales questionnaire or aptitude test can add one more data point.

How long should an SDR role-play be?
About eight minutes, plus a short second round after one piece of coaching works well as an example. That's long enough to see an opener, an objection and a meeting ask.

Should SDR candidates take a personality test?
It's optional. Sales questionnaires like Criteria's SalesAP measure self-reported traits and include checks for exaggerated answers, so treat the result as one input and never as the only reason to reject someone.

Is it legal to give SDR candidates an aptitude test?
Generally yes, if it's job-related, given the same way to everyone and offered with accommodations for disabilities. The EEOC applies a job-related and business-necessity standard when a test screens out a protected group at a higher rate.

How do you assess SDR candidates with no sales experience?
Score behavior, not job titles. Use structured questions about goals and setbacks from any setting, watch how they use coaching in a role-play, and consider an optional aptitude score like the CPT.

Does the Career Potential Test measure sales ability?
No. It measures critical thinking, reading, writing and math. Use it alongside sales exercises, not instead of them.

Hear from capable SDR applicants without sales resumes

Add the free Career Potential Test to your job posting as an optional qualification. No account or setup fees.

Set up the CPT for free

Sources